He reminds me a lot of Andy Dalton and while Dalton is a pretty good QB, I don't think if he were to be drafted today, he would be worth an early 1st round pick and more of a mid 1st. Adding McGlinchey would give Shanahan what he likes and give the 49ers their heir at left tackle. filthymcnasty3 says: Just mere months remain until the draft, as prospects gather to kickstart their careers and fulfill lifelong dreams. Is he purposely ranking QBs like this to get people talking? That INT from 2017? 70 on the Simms listing of NFL quarterbacks. He can beat offensive tackles almost any which way you can imagine. Brees Very much like Rodgers. The San Francisco 49ers could look to bolster the secondary or look for insurance for Reuben Foster's uncertain future. This never made any sense to me. If you spend a few minutes on the internet, you're going to find a plethora of people trying to predict what teams will do when the draft kicks off Thursday. The biggest thing, though, is Evans is a three-down linebacker with good size (6'3", 234 lbs) and top-tier athleticism. Maybe if Rodgers played better he would make his coach look better like Brady does. I wish Vander Esch was a bit more physical, but that often develops at the pro level. Wilson has to figure out how not to get killed again this year. #NBCSports #ChrisSimmsUnbuttoned #NFLDraft2019 Subscribe to NBC Sports: https://www.youtube.com/nbcsports. Simms finished his career appearing in 23 games with a 58.1% completion percentage, 12 TDS, 18 Ints and a 69.1 QB rating. He'll instantly improve the Washington defense. If you're one-on-one with him, he can break your ankles. This is why Smith can have an immediate impact. Eagles. Chris Simms' 2021 NFL Draft: Zach Wilson 'clearly' the No. McGlinchey is an athletic lineman. RELATED:What Colts offer to Bears for No. You must be logged in to leave a comment. "I have the least questions about Lamar Jackson,"hesaid. Played against big talent. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Well, that isn't what you'll find here. Last years 2022 NFL Draft saw DE Travon Walker taken as the No. This is why it's Derwin James all the way here for me. Tittle, so based on your logic, I guess he must have had a lot of great games and belongs in the top 50. Moore phenomenal at playing the ball in the air, and he'll make life easier on Dak Prescott. 10. But I also think he could end up how everyone wanted Vick to end up, I imagine his work ethic is much better than a young Vick's. He can be a force in the run game, too. Wentz Draft week is an exciting time in the NFL. What qualifies Chris Simms to rank a quarterback? Chark are more physically talented than Ridley. If you base it solely on last year it wouldnt be right, but it does make sense. LOL. Chubb's addition would also automatically put the team in the conversation for having the best pass-rusher duo in football with him and Garrett. QB #36 Tyrod TaylorA backup I like, but I wish you could depend on him to stay healthy. Cousins. At the worst, drafting Vander Esch would give Tennessee a very good 3-4 outside linebacker for years. None of @CSimmsQBs contacts across the NFL have him ranked that high. Davis is missing from a lot of people's mock draftswhich I don't quite understandand he's exactly the kind of guy Belichick will jump on. They could take a tight end, and they could go wide receiver as well. Maybe we should let him play a full season before anointing him a top 10 quarterback. ___________. Chris Simms rating QBs is like Trump rating Presidents. 1 spot for the majority of the season, a Texans victory against the Colts ultimately handed the top position to the Chicago Bears. People talk about his accuracy, but his pass-protection was poor, and he had the worst talent around him of any of these guys but hes got the biggest upside of anyone in the class. Chris Simms' 2022 NFL Draft QB Rankings: Why Matt Corral stands out Brady He wins, and wins when it counts, with the rings to prove it. If you, like me, do not consume college football religiously and/or grind prospect tape (Ryan Phillips is responsible for that sort of thing at The Big Lead), this is a scalding take. Id guess dead last. You can see who did by checking out the segment, and you can chime in with your thoughts regarding the sanity or lack thereof regarding his selections in the comments. Josh Rosen : r/nfl 5 yr. ago by ShamrockShaman Raiders Chris Simms Rankings of the 2018 QB Draft Class: 1.) I dont think Patriots fans have a big problem with Rodgers being ranked number #1 (especially from Simms who loves Rodgers). If youre going to rank the best quarterbacks in the NFL right now, the criterion should be what quarterback would you want playing for you in a Super Bowl. We dont even know IF he can play a full game now, OR if he even has any arm strength after SHATTERING his Shoulder last year? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. So McCarthy is good enough to get them that far but when they come up short its always on him and Rodgers can do no wrong? The Giants are closer than many people think. Good accuracy, good decision making, and a good athlete. I think he's 7th best. Thats why hes the best in the game. I don't get what's not to like about Chark. In recent years, however, the line has been a joke, and Russell Wilson has been running for his life. Rovers But it's hard to win in the NFL with a QB who is just trying not to lose. Last year, he had Joe Burrow and Justin Herbert as his top two prospects. Top 5. Now I know to not give credence to anything Simes has to say. Allen may need a little time to adjust to the pro game, but he's the best fit for a Todd Haley scheme and for what the Browns will want to do offensively. This is why it makes sense to add Iowa's James Daniels. Drafting Payne would add both youth and talent at an area of need for Cincinnati. Not really. Now, he is an NFL analyst for Bleacher Report. RELATED: 2023 NFL draft order: Top 18 picks are set with Bears at No. The question I'm asking if I'm in charge of the Ravens is who'll be our next Terrell Suggs? The top five QBs thus far this season, based on performance weighted by circumstances, are Mahomes, Goff, Brees, Cousins, and Rodgers. Be sure to subscribe toChris Simms Unbuttonedfor more on the2022 NFL season as well as an unfiltered look at the NFL, featuring player access, unabashed opinion, X&O film breakdown, and stories from a life in and around football. Im not arguing that Rogers isnt more gifted. He also had 75 carries for 82 yards and five touchdowns. 7. Texans may have a diamond in the rough, and he deserves a shot to prove it#SimmsTop40, #34 Tyler HuntleyPut in a tough spot last year, middle of a playoff race vs a brutal schedule w/ diminished supporting cast. Rodgers is in a class by himself. Reminds me of Tony Romo in that regard. But Simms' recent history with this sort of thing suggests that his opinion is worth considering. Wynn will help improve the Buffalo running game and will help protect AJ McCarron and/or Mayfield from the interior pass rush. It wouldn't hurt to have another downfield playmaker, but that doesn't fit Blake Bortles' strengths. "I played right and left guard," Daniels explained, per Mark Emmert of HawksCentral.com. He's fun, has a great personality and is a marketing executive's dream. However, general manager Bob Quinn and new head coach Matt Patricia both came from the New England Patriots, and I don't believe they value the running back position enough to take one here. Not everyone has to conform to my POV. James doesn't want to just hit youhe wants to take your head off. Look at their stats and wins for the last three years and theyre nearly identical. What qualifies Chris Simms to rank a quarterback? The guy has been outcoached too many times for this to be a coincidence. [I've] seen him throw the touch. These rankings are borderline ridiculous. But I would never want him starting for my football team. Watson Third String QB! How is Cousins not in the top 15? He's the best player in the draft and the type of running back who comes around only once a decade. Lamar Jackson, 2.) I am glad Chris Simms pulled his head out of his A*s to do the debate with Florio. Chris Simms reveals unconventional 2021 NFL Draft QB rankings - 247Sports There's a ton to like about Jackson, and I do like a ton about him, but it's hard to get too hyped about a guy who can't get above 60% completions in college. I know the Dolphins like Mayfield too, so I won't be surprised if the Bills make a trade to leapfrog them. He wasnt even top 10 when he was healthy. 1 QB. His results dont add up to TB12 or Wilson. Brady has Belichick. So most years the Packers win the division and end up in at least the divisional round of the playoffs, if not the NFCCG. Discussion I got bored and tried to make a file that shows Chris Simms position rankings over the last several years. He is one of the least talked-about prospects in this draft, but he deserves to go in the first round. Brady RELATED: Bears land No. Knows how to read defenses and move in the pocket. Chris Simms QB rankings. 24. We just put more stock in the NFL ranking that had Brady as the overall #1 coming into the 2018 season over a guy that has shown his bias against the Pats and Brady in the past. Newton Allen completed just 56-percent of his passes over the last two seasons. If I'm the Cleveland Browns, I'm taking Josh Allen at No. 1, followed by Clemson's Trevor Lawrence, with Mac Jones, Kellen Mond, Justin Fields and Trey. Patriots fans will go nuts which is perfectly understandable. ESPN, ABC, and NFL Network will air all seven rounds of the 2023 NFL Draft. 1 overall quarterback on his board entering the 2018 draft. C. Simms, the NFL analyst and former NFL quarterback, correctly ranks Carson Wentz ahead of Dak Prescott in his ranking of every starting QB in the league. QB #37 Gardner MinshewHe's a natural QB. Without Brady, the Pats dont come back from a 28-3 deficit against the Falons. We've seen snippets, but it never quite gets there. _________________. It's hard to find many instances where wide receivers got open against him, plus he'll quickly be in the mix as one of the top punt returners in football. I know Bill Belichick wants two man-cover corners on his defense. He's built a lot like Solder with long arms (34 ) and above-average height (6'9"). August 23, 2018 at 11:21 am, Viking fans will go nuts which is hilarious. He has a great base, always keeps his feet under him and churning and won't be overpowered. Florio knows whats up. Brady is 41, Rodgers is excellent. 1 overall pick, and nothing has changed since. Stafford He can be a Pro Bowl free safety as a rookie, but he also has the versatility to play cornerback or nickelback if Tampa Bay needs him to. Earlier this Summer, Chris Simms released his highly anticipated list of top 40 quarterbacks in the NFL. If youre going to rank the best quarterbacks in the NFL right now, the criterion should be what quarterback would you want playing for you in a Super Bowl. And I saw improved accuracy last season, with some high difficulty throws in a offense that does not help its QB.#SimmsTop40, #32 Sam DarnoldMoves well, quick release, good intermediate/short passer. While Chubb doesn't remind me of a Khalil Mack, Von Miller or even a Myles Garrett coming out, he's close. ICYMI 2022 NFL Draft order: Complete list of every pick from Round 1 through Round 7, Quarterbacks 21 to 40 in the @CSimmsQB top 40 QB countdown. I thought some of the crew here on PFT could not get more clueless. Brees These two picks, however, didnt quite pan out, as Fenimore played only 10 games and Harmon opted to leave professional football for a career in Hollywood and duty in the U.S. military during World War II. Honorable mention: Winston, Goff, Carr and Mariota. Tittle in their Top 50 QBs of all time. The unnamed Pats assistant'(gopher) in OConners book. I like Roquan Smith for the Oakland Raiders at No. Big reason why Zimmer has been building this defense. (Sign up for our FREE email newsletter and do not miss any Browns breaking news during this important off-season!). While Mayfield does have some drawbacks, he is the third-best quarterback in this class. CHRIS SIMMS RELEASES HIS 2020 NFL DRAFT QUARTERBACK RANKINGS ON "CHRIS SIMMS UNBUTTONED" PODCAST Simms' Top Five Prospects: Joe Burrow (#1), Justin Herbert (#2), Jordan Love (#3), Tua Tagovailoa (#4), and Jacob Eason (#5) "It's the cleanest film I've ever seen from a college quarterback." - Simms on Joe Burrow 3 overall, everyone knew it was to get a quarterback. 16. Smith There's one glaring weakness for the Pittsburgh Steelers, and it should be obvious. The New York Jets have reportedly not yet scheduled a pre-draft visit with Darnold. This mock draft is based primarily on my research and analysis. He has quick hands and can disengage blocks as fast as anyone in the draft. Rodgers Hmm Andrew Luck, even tho he aint played for the past two years lol Chile, pleeze lol. He's a perfect 4-3 defensive tackle. Adding Ward would ensure their defense doesn't take a step back along the way. Vea is a jaw-dropping player, and I wouldn't be shocked if he goes higher. NBC Sports Philadelphia's Dave Zangaro had both quarterbacks ranked a bit lower than Simms in his recent NFL quarterback rankings. Mike Florio and Chris Simms during the 2018 NFL . Bleacher Report NFL Analyst Chris Simms evaluates this year's NFL Draft QB prospects. 17, but I have several concerns about him. Holding down the fort, but didn't do anything last yr to prove he's the Lions future.#SimmsTop40. 70 of Simms' league-wide quarterback rankings. NFL quarterback rankings 2022: Chris Simms' top 40 QB countdown ahead of upcoming NFL season. 16. He could be. Theres certainly some distance between the quality of #1 to #3. The 2023 NFL Draft begins on Thursday, April 27 and ends on Saturday, April 29. The 6'1" Davis is phenomenal in man coverage, and he usually played on an island. The Browns could win this draft by making this move. ZenMaster. ************************************. I don't know if I could pass on Jackson at #28 and I'm confident he will. Lawrence has been wearing the crown of the Next Big Thing for years. Chris Simms: Sam Darnold is the fifth best quarterback - theOBR.com I like to take into account highest potential (ceiling) so I'm not very high on Darnold as I think his ceiling isn't very high but his floor is 2nd highest behind Rosen. Im not arguing that Rogers isnt more gifted. 1. But inconsistent mechanics lead to inconsistent accuracy.He's a game manager w/ a stronger arm. This is why finding a new running mate for Stephon Gilmore will be imperative. And they likely get beat by a lot more than 8 points in last years SB. Former NFL quarterback Chris Simms made waves last year by placing Jaguars quarterback Blake Bortles at No. Without him, they would be 4-12 or 5-11 every year. This will help take pressure off Wilson. August 23, 2018 at 12:25 pm, The Packers are 7-9 without Rodgers every year. Even the #1 Manning vs. 6th round Brady mirrors #1 Luck vs mid round Wilson. He gets upfield, and he disrupts. He moves well in space when pass blocking, and he's extremely powerful at the point of attack in the run game. The skinny: Easily the most surprising selection in Chris Simms' quarterback rankings is Kellen Mond, a player considered a mid to lower-tier prospect two months out from the draft. Chris Simms Position Rankings through the years. Always quick to discount any success and just give it to scheme and coaching. And his health is an issue on top of it. The Packers are 7-9 without Rodgers every year. Chris Simms' Crazy QB Rankings Deserve Benefit of the Doubt Moore is the perfect weapon to pair with Ezekiel Elliott because opposing defenses will think twice about leaving him one-on-one in coverage. Kansas City quarterback Patrick Mahomes sits in the number one spot while Buffalo's Josh Allen ranks second. Rodgers is saddled with the second coming of Marty Schottenheimer. General Manager John Dorsey acquired veteran quarterback Tyrod Taylor in a trade with the Buffalo Bills. Smith can be Oakland's version of Vontaze Burfict. Id have to say Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson make sense as the top two quarterbacks because Rodgers makes a terrible team a playoff contender every year, and Wilson started to do the same thing last year as he dragged that team as far as it could go. However, there's a bigger hole at wide receiver. ______________. 2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved, Some of his pro comparisons are outrageous, also have Wilson above Lawrence on draft boards, Ryan Phillips is responsible for that sort of thing at The Big Lead, an entire feature video for Bleacher Report. He will neutralize interior pass-rushers, which will also make life easier on Wilson. The first draft in NFL history took place at Philadelphias Ritz-Carlton Hotel, where the nine teams in existence at the time gathered to select from a pool of 90 players. 2) Brady Which is a roundabout way of saying, You should watch it.. I see the talent. The NFL analyst and former quarterback is known for his yearly QB draft rankings has a surprise pick at No. However, they have guys they've drafted, and I believe Cincinnati will give them at least one more year to develop. Luck should not be on the list at all. CBS Sports is a registered trademark of CBS Broadcasting Inc. believes that the decision comes down to Darnold or Allen, have reportedly not yet scheduled a pre-draft visit with Darnold. IMO those 4 are on their own level. Chris Simms spent eight seasons playing in the NFL with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Denver Broncos and Tennessee Titans. I wont argue too much if someone wants to put him ahead of Brady, although I disagree. Chris Simms' Film Room: Breaking Down Draft's Top QBs He's aggressive, has a high motor and a ton of upside. I simply can't look at the remaining quarterback prospects and see any of them as a guaranteed franchise QB. Learn how your comment data is processed. NFL Draft 2020: Chris Simms' Top 5 Quarterback Rankings - YouTube Sure, but the quarterback position isn't set for the long term, and Jackson is the signal-caller with the most upside in the draft. 7. He's a consistent, accurate thrower, and the Jets should have to change little about their offense to transition from Josh McCown to Rosen. Good thing the VIkings have a top 5 defense every year, and dont need a top 10 QB to be competitive. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. See below to find out who made the top 5 names for each position. I could see them going tight end, too. QB #38 Teddy BridgewaterHe is the ultimate backup. Click here for the full list of participants. His arm might not even be as good as Bridgewater, but he knows how to play. 1 quarterback, there is a lot to like about Allen. The rest of the list quickly gets interesting. Kerry Collins also has similar career stats to Y.A. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers could use help along the offensive line, but they should be able to find it at the top of Round 2. On the latest episode of The Simms & Lefkoe. I won't predict trades because, well, that's just as silly as pretending to know what teams are thinking. ORLANDO, FL - MARCH 26: San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan speaks with Pro Football Talk Radio's Mike Florio and Chris Simms during the 2018 NFL Annual Meetings at the Ritz Carlton . Posting Freak. 2. Alabama's Rashaan Evans is the perfect guy to take over for Shazier. But this is a results business. They're going to grab Penn State running back Saquon Barkley, and that's what I'd do as well. Simm's ranking probably won't. There's no questions about Lamar.". When Simms ranks RBs or defenses, where oh where will the Packers be? Where does it say the stats I posted are the only reason I think Phil Simms is a top 50 QB? I'm going with Josh Rosen. He'll be in an offense that knows how to utilize all his skills, and he'll have other weapons around him to command defensive attention. . Hell be on the list by the end of the year, Hell be on the list by the end of the year Simms does not see the appeal in Darnold. Coverage of the latest news from around the NFL is available all year round on PFTs Peacock channel. I'm also not positive Mayfield's personality will be attractive to Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott, who is a strict disciplinarian, but Mayfield has the arm talent and the decision-making needed to succeed in Buffalo. Obviously anyone who is not a complete clueless clown has both Phil Simms and Y.A. 2017 NFL Mock Draft: Chris Simms' Final Predictions Rodgers is saddled with the second coming of Marty Schottenheimer. A mediocre expert as well. number 1 to 5 overall: Josh Rosen (Obvious choice) , Lamar Jackson (Upside is too high to ignore and not as big of a chance to bust as Allen), number 6 to 11: Sam Darnold (Average QB), Mayfield (more of a risk but higher upside than Darnold), Mid to Late 1st: Josh Allen (No matter how high his upside is, he is a massive project and will only succeed with good coaching and sitting behind one of the aging vets in Brees, Roethlisberger, Rivers, Eli or Brady for a year or two). Because of the Simmms name he gets to have a weekly ranking and he has a Rodgers love and then no matter the order after that. Simms had one great game in his life, in the Super Bowl, kind of like Timmy Smith for the Redskins. I got to watch him in person at every Notre Dame home game last season, and he never failed to impress. Vikings Fan here: Trevor Lawrence is the most coveted quarterback prospect in recent memory. These are superstar traits. I like his arm, he really reminds of Michael Vick but taller. I could see him as a starter one day.#SimmsTop40, #33 Geno SmithIt's been a long time since his NY struggles. _________. August 23, 2018 at 2:54 pm, I was replying to one of your fellow clowns who said Phil Simms has had one great game in his life ), The list of those who did appears in the video attached to this post. Great point. How does Stafford belong in the top 15 but not COusins? And they likely get beat by a lot more than 8 points in last years SB. The one thing the Bears are missing is a big-time middle linebacker. 8. Pickett is expected to fill the shoes left by Ben Roethlisbergers retirement, but it remains to be seen what his dynamic will look like with fellow Pittsburgh QBMitchell Trubisky when Week 1 arrives. Baker Mayfield, 4.) 9. Phil Simms had one great game in his life. But enough to unseat Lawrence and his three years' worth of momentum? I figured I'd share this because some of the rankings are quite interesting. Viking fans will go nuts which is hilarious. Saints had 2 probowl running backs punching em in. I think the quarterback class is a hair overrated," Simms said via MMQB.com. The Packers need elite QB play on free plays and phantom facemask calls to win games. Brees, as of just last season, lead the entire NFL among active starters in completion percentage, and was 4th in passing yards.. on a team with 2 probowl running backs.. Back in 2015-2016, he said that Jared Goff was nothing special and that he didnt see him having it and that he thought Christian Hackenberg was the better QB because of his special arm strength. His ridiculously strong arm and running expand this offense.But I have questions. One of the biggest questions is already answered: what rookie quarterbacks will make the list? 1. 2005-2023 CBS INTERACTIVE ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. The conclusion of Week 18 officially set the draft order for non-playoff teams and, despite the Houston Texans holding on to the No. Any fool who thinks Phil Simms is not a Top 50 all time QB is either 12 yrs old or as clueless about the NFL as a rock. That is why Notre Dame's Quenton Nelson is an easy choice at No. 6. Can the Packer fans say the same thing? NFL analyst Chris Simms has taken a lot of heat over the past 24 hours for his controversial QB rankings. He's a tremendous athlete, he's physical and he'll be able to do everything the Steelers ask him to do. 2018 was Simms' most impressive act. His short-area quickness is also phenomenal, as evidenced by his 6.71-second three-cone drill and 3.98-second short shuttle. It doesn't make a lot of sense to try to determine which guys teams want when the first couple of picks could throw those desires out the window. B/R's Chris Simms Ranks Lamar Jackson as His No. 1 QB in 2018 NFL Draft Roethlisberger Everyone cries about click-bait all of the time but Chris Simms entire career has been using his dad's fame and clickbait takes he can't even defend. For a team that's a little soft in the middle of the defense, James would add a lot. He's also the draft's most explosive receiver with the ball in his hands. ET on NBCSN. Hmm Andrew Luck, even tho he aint played for the past two years lol Chile, pleeze lol. The Arizona Cardinals could add a variety of players. Getting a No. 70 on the Simms listing of NFL quarterbacks. He's a bit lean, but I don't really mind that too much. If the Cardinals want to throw him in sub-packages as a runner or a receiver as a rookie to get him used to the speed of the game, that's great. He can use his speed to get around the edge (he ran a 4.64-second 40 at the combine), and he can power through if the edge isn't there. Register now! He's a legitimate playmaker. The Minnesota Vikings are another team without many glaring needs. He had the best Wonderlic score among top quarterback prospects, has elite size at 6'5", 237 pounds, has elite athleticism for that size and has as an arm that is John Elway-esque.